If You Understand Food, You'll Understand This Important Songwriting Tool



The Music Maker's Journal

Read Time: 3.2 minutes

Welcome to The Music Makers Journal, where every week I share battle-tested insights from music industry pros to help artists, producers, and musicians streamline their creative process.


What's in store for today:

Master The Emotional Palette of Music: A Simple Guide to Key Colors


Hey there, music makers!

You know what fascinates me almost as much as music? Food.

In fact, if I wasn’t obsessed with music, I’d probably be doing something in the culinary arts. Here’s why I bring this up – I recently realized that understanding key colors in music is a lot like understanding fundamental food types.

Think about this: Just as pizza, tacos, and wings each create distinct experiences and emotional responses when we eat them, different key colors in music create unique emotional environments for our listeners. Pizza needs its essential elements – dough, sauce, and that perfect fire-oven heat. The same applies to key colors - each has its fundamental building blocks that give it its distinct character.

So where am I going with this?

A few years ago, while exploring Berklee's online music curriculum, I stumbled upon two great books:

  1. Great Songwriting Techniques by Jack Perricone and
  2. The Songwriter's Workshop: Harmony by Jimmy Kachulis.

Perricone's book introduced me to the concept of tonal environments while Kachulis' book highlighted that most popular songs use one of five specific tonal environments (also called key colors).

Let's call them key colors because that sounds more musician-friendly.

The Five Essential Key Colors

Like our favorite foods, each of these key colors creates a distinct emotional environment. Here are the 5 essential ones:

  1. Major
  2. Minor
  3. Mixolydian
  4. Dorian
  5. Blues

Now, you might be thinking – “This sounds like it’s about to get really theoretical.”

Don’t worry! While we could dive deep into modes and complex theory (trust me, that could be several newsletters on its own), today we’re keeping it practical and accessible.

As Perricone explains in his book:

“Gaining control over your tonal materials will help you become a better musician and a better songwriter. If you know how to establish a key and understand harmonic functions, you will be able to substitute one harmony for another and control the tonal movements within your song.”

How I'm Learning to Hear Key Colors

Let me share the three-step process that is currently helping me understand and internalize these different tonal environments:

  1. Association with Songs: Connect each key color with songs you already know and love. For example, Billie Jean by Michael Jackson uses the dorian key color.
  2. Learn the Scale: Understand the basic scale structure of each key color. Focus on the scale used in the song that you're studying.
  3. Learn the Chords: Familiarize yourself with the diatonic chords used to define each key color. Again, apply this practice to the song that you're studying.

The beauty of this approach?

You’re always connecting theory back to actual music you enjoy. It’s like learning to cook by actually tasting the food, not just reading recipes.

🎯 Challenge for the Week

Here’s something fun to try:

Pick three of your favorite songs and try to identify their key colors. Don’t worry about being “right” – just start training your ears to notice these different tonal environments. What emotions do they evoke? How do they make you feel?


🧠 Quote of the week

“Songwriters often make pre-compositional choices before writing a song. Some of these choices include tonal considerations (scales, chord forms, tonal environment), music style (ballad, dance, etc.) tempo, etc.” - Jack Perricone

❤️ Favorite Things This Week

Here are the books that I am currently reading.

  1. The Songwriter Workshops: Harmony by Jimmy Kachulis
  2. Great Songwriting Techniques by Jack Perricone
  3. The Guide to Going Viral: The Art and Science of Succeeding on Social Media by Brendan Kane

You can find links to these books and more resources that I've been getting great value from on my resources page.

Enjoy your week,

Melvin Darrell

When you're ready, here are 3 ways I can help

Whenever you're ready, there are 3 ways I can help you:

  1. Music Maker's Chord Progression Database: Never run out of chord progressions again. Get instant access to over 100 ready-to-use chord progressions. Everything you need to compose original songs, improvise faster, and produce unique tracks.
  2. Independent Producers Acceleration Playbook: I have a helpful and simple guide for self-producing artists and new music producers. This guide helps you understand how to make things and shows you how to set up or improve your studio. It has all the important stuff you need to know, like the tools you should have, great books and classes to learn more, and fun ideas for making money!
  3. 1 on 1 Production Coaching: I’ve been producing for 10 years and helping creators while serving as an audio specialist at Rec Philly. I lead many of their producer club workshops, and I’d love to hang out on Zoom! We can brainstorm one of your ideas, work on developing a project for you, or just chat about the production process.

Say hello on your favorite social platform:

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Melvin Darrell

WEEKLY INSIGHTS THAT TRANSFORM HOW YOU HEAR, UNDERSTAND, AND CREATE HARMONIC PROGRESSIONS.

Read more from Melvin Darrell

Read in browser | Read Time: 4 minutes Hey music makers! Been playing with some old favorites lately and found myself smiling at those perfect moments when chords just land in all the right places.That’s the magic of cadences, music’s built-in punctuation that turns simple progressions into emotional journeys. Let’s explore these musical signposts together. Inspired by feedback like this and by questions from readers like you, I’ve been quietly building something new: a full harmony learning...

Read in browser | Read Time: 4.5 minutes Hey music makers! Ever feel stuck with the same seven chords in a major key? You're not alone - that limitation can make your progressions feel predictable and boxed in. Today, we're exploring how borrowed chords give you strategic access to all 12 chords, transforming Louis Armstrong's "What a Wonderful World" from ordinary to extraordinary with just one "outside" chord. Gems Around The Web ⚡ Quick Wins: Seven bite-sized theory exercises that break...

Read in browser | Read Time: 4 minutes Hey music makers! Ever wonder why "Hey Joe" sounds so hypnotic? Five simple chords that create incredible tension. Today, we're cracking the code on a chord sequence that moves backward instead of forward, creating that inevitable pull that matches the song's dark story. Gems Around The Web ⚡ Quick Wins: One simple analytical habit that builds harmonic intuition fast. (Threads) 🗝️ Vault Pick C - G - D - A - E - Hear today's retrogression in action with...